Healthcare & Life Sciences updates


Contributed by ENSafrica
Current pharmaceutical invention patent restrictions
  • Africa
  • 09 December 2020

A number of African World Trade Organisation members have supported a proposal to waive certain provisions of the Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) Agreement for the prevention, containment and treatment of COVID-19. It appears that this is an opportune time for many least-developed countries (LDCs) to extend the TRIPS exemptions beyond the COVID-19 pandemic to address the many challenges which they face, especially regarding neglected tropical diseases.

African Union publishes COVID-19 vaccine strategy
  • Africa
  • 05 August 2020

The African Union (AU) recently published a COVID-19 vaccine strategy. The strategy was announced in a communique issued by the AU ministers of health and heads of delegation following a virtual conference on 24 and 25 June 2020. Access to medicine in Africa is a recurring concern and it may be an opportune moment to use the response to the COVID-19 pandemic as a blueprint to secure future access to pharmaceuticals – including vaccines – for Africans.


Contributed by Preslmayr Attorneys at Law
No profit from blood donations
  • Austria
  • 16 June 2021

The Supreme Court recently had to decide whether a lump-sum compensation for expenses must be considered profit. According to Section 8 of the Blood Safety Act (BSG) 1999, blood and plasm donors must not make a profit by donating blood or plasm. The law uses the terms "profit" and "compensation of expenses" only in Section 8(4) of the BSG. The concentration of these terms in one single paragraph shows a clear intent – namely, that profit is prohibited but the compensation of expenses is permitted.

Court dismisses complaint against limitations on sale of medicinal products
  • Austria
  • 28 April 2021

The Act on Medicinal Products and the Trade and Industry Act set strict rules on the sale of medicinal products. The German-Austrian drugstore chain, dm, brought a constitutional complaint against these limitations. In a decision which is likely to disappoint those in favour of market liberalisation, the Constitutional Court recently dismissed the complaint.

Ascertainment of (dis)conformity of in vitro diagnostics
  • Austria
  • 10 March 2021

The Supreme Court of Justice recently found that a party involved in the marketing of in vitro diagnostics devices did not infringe the Act on Medical Devices or EU Directive 98/79/EC because the devices in question bore the CE mark. The decision clarifies that only the Federal Office for Safety in Healthcare is competent to ascertain whether a CE mark is correctly affixed.

Medical information duty: what constitutes reasonable steps to contact a patient?
  • Austria
  • 03 February 2021

The medical information duty comprises the obligation to inform a patient of possible dangers and negative consequences of a treatment or failure to have such treatment. This information duty exists not only if the patient's consent to a medical treatment is required, but also if the patient must make an informed decision to refrain from having further medical treatment. However, as demonstrated in a recent Supreme Court case, patients must allow their doctor to provide such information.

Restriction of freedom in nursing homes due to risk of COVID-19 infection
  • Austria
  • 06 January 2021

The Supreme Court recently ruled that nursing homes can restrict residents' freedom by isolating them in their room. The resident in question had been isolated in his room in an attempt to prevent the spread of COVID-19 among the other nursing home residents. This decision shows the interaction between protecting the freedom of nursing home residents and challenges caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.


Contributed by ALTIUS
Creation of loco-regional hospital networks exempt from merger control rules
  • Belgium
  • 19 May 2021

The new act of 29 March 2021 explicitly and generally exempts operations which create loco-regional hospital networks from the obligation to notify the Belgian Competition Authority (BCA). This new amendment might come as a surprise. It contradicts the BCA's July 2020 note, which reiterated that competition law rules concerning merger control fully apply to the creation of local hospital networks as required under the act of 28 February 2019.

Can Belgian companies use EU vaccine certificates?
  • Belgium
  • 05 May 2021

To fight the COVID-19 pandemic, the EU Commission is setting up a vaccine passport system (the so-called 'Digital Green Certificate') to enable European citizens to travel easily and safely within the European Union in Summer 2021. This article examines whether Belgian companies may also use these certificates for other purposes (eg, to authorise or prohibit access to private places depending on a citizen's vaccination status).

Must AstraZeneca supply the European Union with sufficient COVID-19 vaccines under Belgian law?
  • Belgium
  • 10 February 2021

AstraZeneca recently announced that it would reduce the supply of its COVID-19 vaccine to the European Union in the first quarter of 2021 to 31 million doses. Questions have therefore arisen as to what extent AstraZeneca is under a contractual obligation to supply the European Union with the initially planned 80 million doses, and what role its UK manufacturing sites should play in this regard. To answer these questions, this article examines the parties' rights and obligations under Belgian law.

BCA suspects Caudalie of imposing minimum resale prices on distributors and limiting active and passive online sales
  • Belgium
  • 20 January 2021

Following dawn raids carried out in 2018, the Belgian Competition Authority's Investigation and Prosecution Service has opened an investigation regarding alleged anti-competitive practices committed by Caudalie, a French cosmetics company specialising in vinotherapy, after a Belgian pharmacist complained that his supplier was imposing a pricing policy on him.

Which COVID-19 vaccines are on the menu for Belgium?
  • Belgium
  • 23 December 2020

Belgium is following the lead of the European Commission and the European Medicines Agency with respect to its COVID-19 vaccine strategy. The European Commission, on behalf of EU member states, has already concluded six advance purchase agreements with vaccine suppliers for a potential total of almost 2 billion doses. Belgium's share presently amounts to a total of 22.4 million vaccines. Purchasing is expected to begin in early January 2021.


Contributed by Smart & Biggar
Court upholds validity of one pneumococcal vaccine patent but holds two others invalid
  • Canada
  • 26 May 2021

The Federal Court recently issued a decision on the validity of three patents relating to Pfizer's PREVNAR 13, a 13-valent pneumococcal polysaccharide protein conjugate vaccine. Merck had sought to impeach Wyeth's patents on the basis that it believed that Wyeth (now Pfizer) would assert the patents against its 15-valent pneumococcal polysaccharide protein conjugate vaccine, V114. The court upheld the validity of one of Wyeth's patents but declared the other two invalid.

Federal Court of Appeal upholds Federal Court decision finding Shire's VYVANSE patent valid
  • Canada
  • 21 April 2021

The Federal Court of Appeal has dismissed Apotex's appeal of the Federal Court decision which held that the claims of Canadian Patent 2,527,646 were valid and prohibited the minister of health from issuing a notice of compliance to Apotex for its lisdexamfetamine product (Shire's VYVANSE) until the patent's expiry. The prohibition application was consolidated with Apotex's action seeking a declaration of invalidity and non-infringement.

Patentability of diagnostic methods – has the Patent Office drawn the line?
  • Canada
  • 07 April 2021

IP offices have long grappled with whether a medical diagnostic constitutes a traditionally patentable concrete or physical method or instead is merely an unpatentable and intangible abstract idea. Although a new diagnostic tool is typically embodied in a physical device or method, the principal advance often lies in the recognition of a previously unknown correlation. New guidance from the Patent Office is a welcome step forward in this difficult area.

Federal Court finds silodosin formulation patent valid but not infringed
  • Canada
  • 24 February 2021

The Federal Court recently issued a decision in a patent infringement action pursuant to Section 6(1) of the Patented Medicines (Notice of Compliance) Regulations relating to silodosin. Although the court found that the patent was not invalid on the basis of obviousness, it also found that the patent had not been infringed.

Innovators challenge final PMPRB Guidelines in new Federal Court application
  • Canada
  • 09 December 2020

Innovative Medicines Canada and numerous research-based pharmaceutical companies recently commenced an application for judicial review of the final Patented Medicine Prices Review Board Guidelines. The guidelines aim to operationalise amendments to the Patented Medicines Regulations scheduled to come into force on 1 January 2021.

Cayman Islands

Contributed by Ogier
Advance healthcare directives
  • Cayman Islands
  • 10 March 2021

In 2019 the Health Care Decisions Act was implemented in the Cayman Islands. This law allows individuals to determine their wishes surrounding medical care and treatment, including end-of-life care, should they become mentally incompetent, and prepare a legal document to this effect. The legal document (known as an 'advance healthcare directive') outlines preferred medical treatments and procedures, such as life support and resuscitation.