Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr

Johannesburg

At Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr (CDH) we believe in partnerships. As one of the largest business law firms in South Africa, the partnerships we cherish and value the most are those we have forged through time and experience with our clients, our people and our communities.

Show more

Updates

Corporate Tax

Recent developments in PBO arena
South Africa | April 20 2018

The South African Revenue Service (SARS) recently issued a press release regarding its intention to investigate possible tax non-compliance in the religious sector. According to SARS, the investigation is in response to, among other things, general reports which have suggested that certain religious organisations and leaders are contravening tax laws and enriching themselves at the expense of tax compliance and their altruistic and philanthropic purpose.

Consecutive asset-for-share transactions
South Africa | April 06 2018

Section 42 of the Income Tax Act allows taxpayers to transfer assets to a company free of immediate tax consequences, provided that certain requirements are met (ie, there is a roll over for tax purposes). However, certain anti-avoidance provisions may be triggered if the company that acquired the assets disposes of them within 18 months of acquisition. The South African Revenue Service recently provided some guidance on this matter in a binding private ruling.

Did the punishment fit the crime? Tax Court reduces understatement penalty imposed by SARS
South Africa | March 30 2018

The imposition of understatement penalties under Chapter 16 of the Tax Administration Act, and the factors to consider when imposing such a penalty, is an issue unresolved by the courts. However, a recent Tax Court judgment has set out some helpful principles in this regard.

Taxation of subsistence allowances – SARS issues new ruling
South Africa | March 23 2018

The South African Revenue Service recently issued Binding Private Ruling 291, which addresses the taxation of subsistence allowances paid by employers to their employees in certain circumstances. The ruling appears to offer guidance regarding the application of Section 8 of the Income Tax Act and suggests that employers may have some leeway in structuring the subsistence allowances that they provide to their employees.

Another ruling on share schemes, but questions remain
South Africa | March 16 2018

The South African Revenue Service (SARS) recently published a binding private ruling on the application of Paragraph 38(1) of the Eighth Schedule to the Income Tax Act to the distribution of shares by a trust to beneficiaries in the context of an employee share scheme. Although SARS stated that Paragraph 38(1) was not applicable to the trust's distribution of shares, the matter is complicated by the interaction between Section 8C of the act and the rules contained in the Eighth Schedule.

SARS provides further clarity on VCCs
South Africa | March 09 2018

The South African Revenue Service (SARS) recently released a binding class ruling which addressed, among other things, the eligibility of a partner in an en commandite partnership to claim a deduction in respect of venture capital shares acquired by the partnership. SARS ruled that subject to the Income Tax Act, each class member will be entitled to claim the deduction pro rata to its proportionate share of the investment in the partnership.

A win against SARS: late delivery of Rule 31 statement
South Africa | February 02 2018

The Tax Court recently delivered a judgment that will be of interest to any taxpayers involved in prolonged disputes with the South African Revenue Service (SARS), particularly where there are delays on the part of SARS. The case involved an application by the taxpayer for default judgment and an application by SARS for condonation for the late filing of its answering affidavit opposing the default judgment application.

Deductibility of legal expenses
South Africa | January 26 2018

For the purposes of determining a party's taxable income derived from carrying on a trade, the Income Tax Act provides for the deduction of legal expenses which arise during or by reason of its ordinary trading operations. However, in order for a taxpayer to deduct legal expenses, they must relate to a claim, dispute or action at law. Further, they must have arisen during or by reason of the taxpayer's ordinary operations undertaken in the course of its trade and must not be of a capital nature.

VAT rulings: how and when to apply
South Africa | December 22 2017

The process of applying for a value added tax (VAT) ruling is quite efficient and comes at no cost to the applicant. Such a ruling provides guidance as to the South African Revenue Service's views on certain transactions before entering into them and therefore mitigates the risks of proposed transactions. As there is virtually no risk in applying for a VAT ruling, it is advisable to apply for such a ruling in cases of uncertainty.

No trade, no deduction: Tax Court issues Section 11(a) judgment
South Africa | December 15 2017

The Tax Court recently issued its decision in a case concerning a taxpayer's claim for R90 million as an expense or loss during the 2007 assessment year, the deduction of which was prohibited by the South African Revenue Service. Among other things, the court had to consider whether the taxpayer had been carrying on the trade of selling coal when it had paid the R90 million and whether the expense had been incurred in the production of income or for trade purposes.

Further revisions to Income Tax Act's debt reduction rules announced
South Africa | December 08 2017

The debt reduction provisions provided for in the Income Tax Act have been the subject of significant debate since their introduction. As a result, the National Treasury included various proposed changes to the provisions in the first draft of the Taxation Laws Amendment Bill 2017. Following consultation on the bill, the National Treasury recently published a revised bill, which contains further significant amendments.

SARS publishes raft of notable Tax Court judgments
South Africa | November 17 2017

Under the Tax Administration Act, a Tax Court judgment regarding an appeal under the dispute resolution provisions contained in the act must be published for general information purposes. The South African Revenue Service recently published a raft of Tax Court judgments that have thus far been handed down in 2017, which provide for interesting reading and cover a broad range of procedural and administrative issues.

Tax Court grants condonation for late filing of appeal
South Africa | November 10 2017

The Tax Court recently addressed the question of whether a taxpayer is entitled to condonation for the late filing of an appeal under the Tax Administration Act. The Tax Court referred to a Constitutional Court judgment which found that a delay cannot be a determining factor in condonation applications. In addition, it noted that other important considerations should be taken into account, such as whether the omission or failure was the applicant's fault and the extent of the delay.

BEPS effect: has Lord Tomlin's famous dictum become obsolete?
South Africa | October 20 2017

Following the implementation of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development's Base Erosion and Profit Shifting Action Plans, which impose country-by-country reporting requirements on multinational enterprises, taxpayers can no longer – or at least cannot easily – strategically escape taxation by shifting their profits to low or no-tax jurisdictions. This is because the South African Revenue Service has become aware of issues regarding tax avoidance and is actively taking steps to address them.

The golden rule: SARS clarifies vendors' entitlement to claim input tax for second-hand gold
South Africa | October 13 2017

Under the Value Added Tax Act, vendors were previously prohibited from claiming notional input tax deductions for the acquisition of second-hand goods comprising gold or goods containing gold in an attempt to curb fraudulent notional input tax deductions regarding the acquisition of gold and gold jewellery. However, the amendment had a negative impact on legitimate transactions in the industry, so the definition of second-hand goods was recently amended in order to limit the extent of the exclusion.

SARS says "pay up", but court says "no": an important case on taxpayers' rights
South Africa | September 15 2017

The Mthatha High Court recently ruled that the South African Revenue Service (SARS) had failed to comply with Section 96 of the Tax Administration Act in ordering an additional assessment of a taxpayer's income tax. The case reaffirms the fact that just as taxpayers have a duty to pay tax, SARS has duties that it must fulfil in order to be entitled to collect this tax.

Proposed amendments to Tax Administration Act
South Africa | September 08 2017

South African Revenue Services decisions are generally subject to the internal remedy available under Section 9 of the Tax Administration Act. However, decisions that are given effect to in an assessment or notice of assessment are excluded, since assessments generally have the separate remedy of objection and appeal. A recent memorandum on the Draft Tax Administration Laws Amendment Bill proposes that such decisions be subject to the remedy under Section 9 of the act.

Getting out what you put in: a recap on input tax deductibility
South Africa | September 01 2017

There has been a great deal of uncertainty surrounding the claiming of value added tax (VAT) input credits, particularly where mixed taxable and non-taxable supplies are made and in the context of expenses relating to corporate actions. This uncertainty regarding the deductibility of input tax credits in certain instances has created a VAT risk for many vendors. The courts and the South African Revenue Service have differing views on this matter.

New bill aims to clarify assumption of contingent liabilities under corporate reorganisation rules
South Africa | August 25 2017

The National Treasury recently published the Draft Taxation Laws Amendment Bill 2017, which proposes to clarify the tax implications that arise when a person assumes contingent liabilities under the corporate reorganisation rules contained in the Income Tax Act. The proposal is to insert a new definition in Section 41 of the act, expressly stating that debt for the purposes of the corporate reorganisation rules includes contingent debt.

Tax treatment of conversion of debt into equity and artificial repayment of debt
South Africa | August 18 2017

In order to assist companies in financial distress, it has been proposed that definitive rules dealing with the tax treatment of conversions of debt into equity be introduced. The Draft Taxation Laws Amendment Bill 2017 therefore proposes that the rules dealing with a debt that has been cancelled, waived or discharged should not apply to a debt that is owed by a debtor to a creditor that forms part of the same group of companies.

Foreign employment income exemption – is this the end?
South Africa | August 11 2017

The Income Tax Act states that if a South African resident works in a foreign country for more than 183 days a year, with more than 60 of those days being continuous, any foreign employment income earned is exempt from tax. The draft Taxation Laws Amendment Bill 2017 proposes to repeal this exemption in its entirety, as the National Treasury has realised that it creates opportunities for double non-taxation. In addition, the exemption has led to the unequal treatment of public and private sector employees.

Further clarification on VAT registration of non-executive directors
South Africa | June 30 2017

In February 2017 the South African Revenue Service published two binding general rulings which provided much-needed clarity on various interpretational issues, but failed to cover certain practical issues. Subsequent publications, media releases and revisions have offered further practical guidance on the manner in which companies and non-executive directors should have dealt with the taxation of their earnings before June 1 2017.

VAT on non-executive director remuneration: more questions than answers?
South Africa | June 23 2017

The South African Revenue Service recently issued Binding General Ruling 41, in which it ruled that non-executive directors (NEDs) should register and account for value added tax (VAT) on their directors' fees where the fees exceed the VAT registration threshold of R1 million in a 12-month period. SARS recently issued an updated ruling in which it determined that, in accordance with the VAT Act, the VAT registration liability date for NEDs was June 1 2017.

Improvements to SARS dispute resolution process
South Africa | June 09 2017

The South African Revenue Service (SARS) recently released a statement regarding improvements that have been introduced to the existing dispute resolution process. According to the statement, SARS is implementing these improvements as part of its ongoing commitment to deliver a better service to taxpayers. The statement refers to the implementation of an electronic request for reasons for an assessment and the introduction of a guided process for SARS's eFiling system, among other things.

New SARS ruling pertaining to restructuring of property portfolio under corporate rules
South Africa | May 26 2017

The South African Revenue Service recently set out the tax consequences for the restructuring of an unlisted property portfolio under the Income Tax Act. The parties to the transaction were a listed company incorporated and resident in South Africa which carried on business as a long-term insurer (the applicant), a company incorporated and resident in South Africa and 100% owned by the applicant and a corporate real estate investment trust to be listed on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange.

Free transport for employees: taxable fringe benefit?
South Africa | April 14 2017

In many businesses, it is common for employers to provide their employees with free or low-cost transport services from their homes to their place of employment. However, under the Income Tax Act, such arrangements could constitute a taxable fringe benefit in the hands of the employees, depending on the circumstances and facts of the case. The South African Revenue Service recently released Binding Private Ruling 262, which deals with this issue.

Ruling on unitised incentive scheme provides little clarity
South Africa | March 31 2017

A recent South African Revenue Service ruling on an employee incentive scheme suggests that Paragraph 80(2) of Schedule Eight of the Income Tax Act (58/1962) applies in respect of any gains realised on a disposal of shares and must be disregarded by the trust where the gains are vested in the beneficiaries. However, the ruling is silent as to whether any such gains must be taken into account for the purposes of calculating the beneficiaries' aggregate capital gains or losses.

Better late than never? Tax Court decision and recent legislative amendments regarding lodging objections
South Africa | March 24 2017

In a recent case, the Tax Court held that the taxpayer had failed to prove that exceptional circumstances had caused the delay in lodging its objection to an assessment issued by the South African Revenue Service (SARS) and dismissed the appeal. In light of the National Treasury's budget shortfall, SARS may be more aggressive in collecting tax in future. This judgment should therefore be taken seriously.

SARS clarifies taxation of non-executive directors
South Africa | March 17 2017

The South African Revenue Service recently issued two binding general rulings which address how non-executive directors should account for tax on their earnings as directors. The rulings determined that companies must not withhold employee pay-as-you-earn tax on amounts paid to non-executive directors and that non-executive directors may claim deductions against their income for certain expenses, provided that they meet the requirements of the Income Tax Act (58/1962).

Section 73 of VAT Act: consequences of unlawful tax avoidance
South Africa | March 03 2017

When disputing a tax debt, especially one involving the complex issue of unlawful tax avoidance, taxpayers should always exercise caution. This sentiment was echoed in a recent judgment which made reference to a taxpayer's dispute with the South African Revenue Service (SARS). SARS had rejected the taxpayer's claim for input tax and concluded that the transaction had been a scheme to obtain an undue tax benefit under Section 73 of the Value Added Tax Act.

The wait is over: SVDP takes effect
South Africa | February 17 2017

Following its announcement in the 2016 Budget Speech, the legislation governing the Special Voluntary Disclosure Programme (SVDP) has finally come into effect. The amount payable under the SVDP will be equal to the amount of the receipts and accruals not declared to the South African Revenue Service, as required by the Estate Duty Act or the Income Tax Act, from which an asset – situated outside South Africa and held between March 1 2010 and February 28 2015 – was wholly or partly derived.

SARS issues ruling on tax accountability following assumption of contingent liabilities in sale of business
South Africa | February 10 2017

The South African Revenue Service (SARS) recently provided guidance on the difficult issue of accounting for tax following the assumption of contingent liabilities on the acquisition of a business as a going concern. Parties should proceed with caution when structuring sale of business agreements, as it is likely that SARS will adopt the position set out in its interpretation note.

The price is not right: advertising and the VAT Act
South Africa | January 27 2017

An efficient advertising campaign is often the difference between a successful and an unsuccessful business venture. However, when advertising the price of their products, businesses must observe the Value Added Tax (VAT) Act. The Advertising Standards Authority of South Africa Directorate recently addressed this matter and upheld a complaint regarding the advertised prices in a print ad for safety wear, which had excluded VAT.

When is an error a bona fide inadvertent error?
South Africa | January 20 2017

The Tax Court recently considered whether the South African Revenue Service was correct to levy an understatement penalty on a taxpayer that had incorrectly claimed the deductible allowance of enhancement income provided for by the Income Tax Act. The taxpayer submitted that the understatement had arisen as a result of a bona fide inadvertent error, as contemplated in Section 222(1) of the Tax Administration Act, and that it therefore did not have to pay a penalty.

An unfortunate experience with SARS
South Africa | January 13 2017

The High Court (Gauteng Division, Pretoria) recently found that the South African Revenue Service (SARS) erred in its finding that the applicant had failed to pay certain amounts of value added tax and incorrectly levied penalties and interest. On the facts, it appeared that the applicant had made payment as required, and that SARS had incorrectly allocated the amount paid. As such, the court granted an order to the effect that SARS must pay interest on the amounts paid by the applicant under protest.

Alas, sometimes you can't appeal Tax Court decisions
South Africa | January 06 2017

A number of cases have examined whether an interim order or decision which does not dispose of a case finally is appealable. In a recent Supreme Court of Appeal case, a taxpayer wanted to appeal, among other things, the Tax Court's decision regarding the onus of proof and duty to adduce evidence first. The court's judgment provides an important warning for taxpayers to consider the applicable legislation and whether an appeal is worthwhile.

Taxable benefits provided to expatriate employees seconded in South Africa
South Africa | December 23 2016

Due to the nature of their business, many multinationals send their employees to work in other countries. Such employees are often subject to taxation in their host country, yet remain tax residents in their home country. The Johannesburg Tax Court recently considered issues that arose as a result of the tax arrangements entered into between the host country employer and its expatriate employees, who were seconded from their home countries to work in South Africa.

SARS rules on donations-related tax consequences of transaction to introduce BEE shareholder into group
South Africa | December 16 2016

The South African Revenue Service (SARS) recently issued a binding private ruling regarding the donations-related tax consequences of a proposed transaction which would introduce a black economic empowerment (BEE) shareholder into a group of companies in order to benefit all of the entities within the group in respect of their BEE scorecard ratings and increase the profitability of the applicant.

Mandatory documentation in transfer pricing transactions: new public notice published
South Africa | December 09 2016

The long-awaited final public notice regarding the record-keeping requirements pertaining to transfer pricing transactions was recently published. While the public notice clarifies the additional record-keeping requirements for transfer pricing transactions, these requirements may increase compliance costs for certain taxpayers. Further, taxpayers risk the South African Revenue Service auditing them and finding that they have failed to keep the required records.

Under the radar: today one tax rate, tomorrow another?
South Africa | December 02 2016

Following the recent release of the first Draft Taxation Laws Amendment Bill 2016 and its explanatory memorandum, the proposed amendments applicable to trusts and employee share schemes have received significant attention. However, another proposed amendment with potentially far-reaching consequences has received little attention, but could result in a taxpayer paying tax at one rate one day and another the next, as determined by the minister of finance.

When debt and creativity meet: recent Tax Court decision
South Africa | November 04 2016

In today's tough economic climate, it is common for companies to consider alternative funding arrangements to fund their activities, which minimises cash-flow obligations to third parties in the short term, while also ensuring compliance with relevant tax legislation. One option to consider is the creation of a loan account by a debtor in favour of a creditor. The Tax Court recently had to address this issue and, specifically, the consequences of Section 22(3) of the Value Added Tax Act.

Deferring tax by using unit trusts
South Africa | October 21 2016

Investors in shares can defer capital gains tax using unit trusts. If a taxpayer transfers listed shares to a unit trust in exchange for units in the trust, the transfer will not give rise to capital gains tax or securities transfer tax, provided that the unit trust meets the requirements under the Collective Investment Schemes Control Act and the transfer meets the requirements under the Income Tax Act.

Cars, taxable supplies and input VAT – what the law says
South Africa | October 07 2016

The Tax Court recently determined whether input tax could be claimed by a close corporation which carried on business in the courier industry on the purchase of a vehicle used to make taxable supplies. Taxpayers whose business involves making taxable supplies and which are vendors in terms of the Value Added Tax Act should ensure that they can claim an input tax deduction on motor vehicles purchased for their business.

Tax exemption of membership-based organisations – time for a rethink?
South Africa | September 16 2016

Membership-based organisations and the willingness of members to pay membership fees are becoming increasingly less attractive as a result of restrictive funding requirements in the Income Tax Act. There may be merit in extending the partial taxation regime currently governing public benefit organisations to membership-based organisations. In this way, membership-based organisations could maintain their tax-exempt status.

Exchange control circular issued in respect of Special Voluntary Disclosure Programme
South Africa | August 26 2016

The Financial Surveillance Department of the South African Reserve Bank recently issued an exchange control circular regarding the information that is required in an application for exchange control relief. The circular forms part of the joint tax and exchange control Special Voluntary Disclosure Programme, which was announced by the minister of finance in the 2016 budget speech.

All in one: another ruling regarding an amalgamation transaction
South Africa | July 22 2016

The South African Revenue Service recently ruled on rollover relief provisions in the Income Tax Act, finding that the disposal by amalgamated companies of their businesses to the resultant company will meet the requirements of an amalgamation transaction. This ruling suggests that under certain circumstances, each amalgamated company may not need to conclude a separate amalgamation transaction with the resultant company to qualify for the rollover relief.

Overruled: SARS expresses interesting view on an amalgamation transaction
South Africa | July 01 2016

The South African Revenue Service (SARS) has traditionally adopted a conservative approach in issuing rulings which approve a tenuous interpretation of the Income Tax Act in favour of the taxpayer. However, in a recent binding private ruling SARS adopted an interesting interpretation of the corporate rollover relief provisions in Section 44 of the act, raising a number of questions.

SARS rules again on capitalisation of loan accounts
South Africa | June 17 2016

The South African Revenue Service has issued a number of rulings regarding the conversion of debt to equity, and recently issued a binding private ruling which again dealt with the matter. The ruling involved a restructure of a group of companies. As part of the restructure, one company in the group (a tax resident in South Africa) acquired a loan account in its wholly owned subsidiary company (a tax resident in another country).

Test case mechanism: weapon to ward off multiple attacks from SARS?
South Africa | May 20 2016

Under the dispute resolution procedures in Chapter 9 of the Tax Administration Act, taxpayers must sometimes defend themselves before court in respect of one tax period while simultaneously objecting to and appealing the same legal issues in respect of earlier or later years of assessment. However, taxpayers may benefit from a test case mechanism provided by the act.

SARS's investigative powers – backstage pass to pending court matters?
South Africa | May 13 2016

Taxpayers are often assessed for more than one tax period at a time. However, problems arise when the issues being investigated by the South African Revenue Service overlap with disputes pending before the Tax Court. The taxpayer must then defend itself in respect of one tax period before court while simultaneously sourcing and providing relevant material pertaining to the same legal issues for an audit of a later tax period.

Amendments to TFI regulations
South Africa | April 29 2016

Following Budget 2016, a number of amendments have been proposed to the laws and regulations that apply to tax-free investments (TFIs). These include amending the Income Tax Act in order to prevent the circumvention of estate duty; removing the requirement to submit dividend tax returns following the receipt of dividends from TFIs; and introducing draft regulations to outline the process for transferring TFIs between service providers.

Tax decision objections and 'exceptional circumstances' – a cautionary tale
South Africa | April 15 2016

A taxpayer that is aggrieved by an assessment or decision of the South African Revenue Service may object to the assessment or decision, but must do so within 30 business days of the date of the assessment. This period may be extended by no more than 21 business days, unless 'exceptional circumstances' caused the delay. The South Gauteng Tax Court recently considered the meaning of this term.

SARS seeks to clarify exemption for foreign employment income
South Africa | March 25 2016

The South African Revenue Service (SARS) recently issued Draft Interpretation Note 16 (Issue 2) for public comment. Compared to the present Interpretation Note 16, the draft note indicates a shift in SARS's interpretation of a tax exemption for foreign employment income under the Income Tax Act. With the draft note, SARS is tightening the requirements for accessing the foreign employment tax exemption without changing the wording of the act itself.

Vendor beware: capital gains tax on instalment sales
South Africa | March 18 2016

Taxpayers should take great care when selling assets where the price is paid in instalments, as the transaction may trigger tricky capital gains tax consequences. This is because where a taxpayer becomes entitled to an amount which is payable in a subsequent tax year (eg, through an asset sale), the full amount must be treated as having accrued to the taxpayer in the current tax year.

Ruling on third-party backed shares
South Africa | March 11 2016

The South African Revenue Service (SARS) recently issued a binding private ruling which dealt with the interpretation and application of Section 8EA of the Income Tax Act. This anti-avoidance provision deems the amount of any dividend or foreign dividend received or accrued to the holder of a preference share to be income (as opposed to exempt income) for tax purposes. The provision applies when the preference share in question is a third-party backed share.

Budget Day alert
South Africa | March 04 2016

Budget Day saw the proposal of a number of measures affecting taxpayers. Key proposals cover the recharacterisation of proceeds in case of share buyback; the conversion of interest into dividends; the submission date of the estimate for the second provisional tax payment for the tax year; the withdrawal of the proposed withholding tax on service fees; and collective investment schemes.

Preservation orders: court sets high bar for SARS
South Africa | February 26 2016

In Commissioner for SARS v Sunflower Distributors CC the High Court recently decided whether a provisional preservation order granted in favour of the South African Revenue Service (SARS) should be made final. The judgment provides some comfort to taxpayers facing such an application by SARS, since it shows that the court will not easily grant such an order and that SARS must provide full disclosure of all the relevant facts.

Interpretation of the term 'substantially the whole'
South Africa | February 19 2016

A new binding general ruling clarifies the interpretation of the term 'substantially the whole' as used in the Income Tax Act. Approved associations, public benefit organisations, recreational clubs and small business funding entities may carry out limited business undertakings; provided that 'substantially the whole' of these undertakings are directed at the recovery of costs, the receipts and accruals are tax exempt.

Proposed extension of existing prescription periods
South Africa | January 22 2016

The Tax Administration Act prescribes the period of limitations for issuance of assessments. A new bill proposes to extend these prescription periods to account for delays arising from failure by the taxpayer to provide requested material, resolution of information entitlement disputes and certain audits and investigations under the Tax Administration Act. The proposed amendments seek to address the issue of delaying tactics used by taxpayers.

Victory for taxpayer in motor vehicle salary sacrifice scheme
South Africa | January 15 2016

The Supreme Court of Appeal recently ruled in favour of the taxpayer in respect of a motor vehicle salary sacrifice scheme. The judgment underlines the importance of employers and employees properly agreeing, understanding and implementing any remuneration structures that contain a salary sacrifice component.

Taxation of trusts in the future
South Africa | January 08 2016

In 2015 the Davis Tax Committee released its first report on estate duty for public comment. The committee was tasked with considering the use of trusts as vehicles employed by taxpayers to divest themselves of their assets during their lifetime, thereby saving estate duty on their death. Its report contained a number of disconcerting recommendations with regard to the taxation of trusts.

Draft bill on carbon tax released
South Africa | December 18 2015

Having been the subject of various discussion papers since 2011, the introduction of a carbon tax in South Africa is becoming a reality with the release of a draft carbon tax bill earlier this month. It has been clear since at least 2013 that South Africa would opt for a carbon tax in order to price carbon, as opposed to an emissions-trading scheme. The draft bill sets out the mechanics of the carbon tax.

Changes to income tax return for trusts
South Africa | December 11 2015

The South African Revenue Service recently amended the ITR12T form (the income tax return for trusts). The amended form incorporates certain legislative changes, makes mandatory certain previously optional fields and includes automatic calculations. The amendments arise from the implementation of system changes to cater for the processing of certain collective investment scheme registrations and value added tax registrations.

Merger of controlled foreign companies
South Africa | November 27 2015

The South African Revenue Service (SARS) recently released a binding private ruling dealing with the merger of two controlled foreign companies (CFCs) for purposes of Section 9D of the Income Tax Act, which provides relief from any exit charge that could arise as a result of one of the merging parties ceasing to be a CFC. SARS ruled that the proposed transaction would constitute an amalgamation transaction, thus triggering relief.

Advance payments by non-residents disposing of immovable property
South Africa | November 20 2015

The 2015 Taxation Laws Amendment Bill proposes an amendment to the Income Tax Act concerning withholding percentages from payments due to non-resident sellers of immovable property situated in South Africa. The proposed amendment raises interesting questions regarding compliance with tax laws through the submission of returns for assessment versus a final withholding tax.

Market value of shares on valuation date
South Africa | October 30 2015

The Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) recently ruled in a case concerning the determination of the valuation date value of shares for the purposes of calculating the capital gain or loss that arose on their disposal. The SCA accepted the South African Revenue Service's claim that the forecast amounts used in the taxpayer's valuation of the shares were unreasonably optimistic.

Disclosure to SARS and treatment of PAYE
South Africa | October 23 2015

Where an employer wishes to regularise its employee's tax affairs through the Voluntary Disclosure Programme and cannot recover the tax directly from the employee, it must pay the pay-as-you-earn tax on behalf of the employee. Such payment constitutes a 'payment of the employee's debt' which triggers a taxable fringe benefit in the hands of the employee.

Definition of 'controlled group company' and 'equity share'
South Africa | October 16 2015

The South African Revenue Service recently released a binding private ruling which considered the meaning of 'controlled group company' and 'equity share' in terms of Section 12J of the Income Tax Act. The ruling concerned an approved venture capital company in terms of Section 12J which proposed to incorporate a new company with two other resident companies.

Disposal by share block company of sectional title units to its shareholders
South Africa | October 02 2015

The provisions of various tax laws allow for rollover relief where a share block company disposes of its property to a shareholder which has rights over that property. A recent ruling by the South African Revenue Service clearly illustrates the application of these provisions, and clarifies that they apply to undivided interests in sectional title units owned by share block companies.

Voluntary disclosure relief to be widened
South Africa | September 25 2015

The Tax Administration Act provides for various forms of relief in respect of disclosures made by qualifying taxpayers of their tax defaults under the Voluntary Disclosure Programme. The recently published Tax Administration Laws Amendment Bill makes a welcome proposal to widen the scope of relief available to qualifying taxpayers to include penalties for the late payment of tax.

Improved tax allowance for photovoltaic power plants
South Africa | September 18 2015

A proposed amendment to the Income Tax Act will accelerate the tax allowance available to photovoltaic (PV) power plants. The proposal allows for a 100% accelerated tax allowance in respect of embedded PV power plants generating up to 1 megawatt for self-consumption. Should the proposal prove successful, small-scale PV solar plants can be expected to adorn the rooftops of corporate offices across South Africa.

Ruling on issue of capitalisation shares
South Africa | August 28 2015

The South African Revenue Service recently ruled on a case in which an applicant (a natural person) held 100% of the equity shares in a resident operating company. The operating company in turn owned 100% of the shares in a dormant resident company (the co-applicant). The parties wished to introduce a black-owned company as a shareholder in the operating company in order to improve its Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) credentials.

Third-party returns – information exchange in line with international standards
South Africa | August 21 2015

In order to introduce the legislative amendments required to implement the tax proposals announced in the 2015 National Budget, the National Treasury recently published a new bill for public comment. One proposal relates to greater tax transparency and the automatic exchange of information between tax administrations in various jurisdictions in order to counter cross-border tax evasion.

Asset-for-share transactions: proposed amendment to anti-avoidance rule
South Africa | August 14 2015

Section 42 of the Income Tax Act provides for tax rollover relief in respect of asset-for-share transactions. Such a transaction generally occurs when a party disposes of an asset to a company, which then issues new shares to the party in return. To prevent abuse, Section 42(5) contains an anti-avoidance provision. The recently released draft Taxation Laws Amendment Bill proposes the clarification of this provision.

Interpretation of exemption provisions
South Africa | June 05 2015

The Tax Court recently issued its ruling in ABC (Pty) Ltd v Commissioner for South African Revenue Service. Although the case concerned secondary tax on companies, which has been replaced by dividends tax, it is interesting to examine how the court dealt with the interpretation of an exemption provision.

Amending a statement of grounds of assessment
South Africa | May 22 2015

The Tax Court has delivered its judgment in a matter concerning, among other things, an application by the South African Revenue Service to amend its statement of grounds of assessment. Rule 13 of the previous rules of the Tax Court and Rule 35 of the new rules allow parties to amend their pleadings on application. However, the issue is the extent to which the courts will allow for such amendments.

SARS clamps down on share buy-backs followed by issue of shares
South Africa | April 17 2015

Taxpayers often enter into arrangements under which a company buys back its own shares held by certain shareholders, and immediately thereafter issues new shares to new shareholders. This practice has long raised tax avoidance concerns for the South African Revenue Service, as it could circumvent the payment of capital gains tax by the shareholder whose shares are bought back.

SARS extends list of reportable arrangements
South Africa | April 10 2015

The commissioner of the South African Revenue Service has issued an important notice under the Tax Administration Act. The notice expands the list of reportable arrangements under Sections 34 to 39 of the act. However, it also excludes from reporting arrangements where the aggregate tax benefit which may be derived by all the participants to the arrangement is less than R5 million.

SARS's power to request relevant material
South Africa | February 27 2015

The South African Revenue Service (SARS) has the power to request a taxpayer or other party to submit relevant material to it. The Tax Administration Laws Amendment Act has now amended the definition of 'relevant material' to mean "any information... that in the opinion of SARS is foreseeably relevant for the administration of a tax act". Thus, it is no longer within the other party's discretion to decide whether material is relevant.

Draft ruling on termination of STC credits and effect on dividends
South Africa | February 20 2015

The South African Revenue Service recently issued a draft binding general ruling that seeks to address the tax position regarding the availability of the secondary tax on companies credits where dividends are declared before April 1 2015, but paid on or after that date.

No evidence justifying penalty
South Africa | January 16 2015

In AB (Pty) Ltd v The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service, the Tax Court ruled that the South African Revenue Service (SARS) failed to provide sufficient evidence to support the penalty that it had imposed on a value added tax vendor. As the penalty was a discretionary decision, the court held that it was allowed to re-hear the entire matter, and the onus was on SARS to lead evidence afresh.

Interpretation of fiscal legislation
South Africa | January 09 2015

In Commissioner SARS v Bosch the Supreme Court of Appeal dealt with the fiscal consequences of a deferred delivery transaction. The judgment is important not only in the context of the meaning of simulation, but also with reference to the way in which legislation should be interpreted, especially regarding Section 8A of the Income Tax Act.

Further changes to secondary transfer pricing adjustment
South Africa | November 14 2014

The draft Taxation Laws Amendment Bill 2014, which the National Treasury and the Revenue Service released earlier this year, proposed changes to the secondary transfer pricing adjustment mechanism. Following criticisms raised by interested parties, the Treasury and the Revenue Service have released a response document to the comments received from the public, as well as a final bill.

Streamlining the VAT registration process: an update
South Africa | September 26 2014

The South African Revenue Service has released a briefing note on the draft regulations for VAT vendor registration. It contains amendments meant to ease the compliance burden of prospective VAT vendors by widening the acceptable range of income and allowing for activities that only make taxable supplies after a period of time.

Securities transfer tax and earnout provisions
South Africa | August 22 2014

Securities transfer tax is usually levied in respect of a sale of shares transaction. However, where a sale of shares is subject to an earnout provision, the issue arises as to how the amount of the securities transfer tax is calculated, specifically in the context of unlisted companies.

Reportable arrangements and retrospectivity
South Africa | July 25 2014

The South African Revenue Service recently issued an updated draft notice listing transactions that constitute reportable arrangements for purposes of Section 35(2) of the Tax Administration Act. The draft notice, once finalised, is intended to replace any previous notices issued in respect of reportable arrangements under Section 80M(2)(c) and Section 80N(4) of the Income Tax Act.

Supreme Court considers administrative fairness in tax disputes
South Africa | July 18 2014

In a recent decision the Supreme Court of Appeal emphasised that, for the sake of fairness and proper court procedure, the South African Revenue Service must clearly state the grounds on which any assessments against a taxpayer are based, and make clear to the taxpayer what it is disputing, so that the taxpayer knows what is required from it to discharge the burden of proof.

Repurchase of preference shares
South Africa | May 30 2014

The South African Revenue Service recently released a binding class ruling (BCR 44) dealing with the tax consequences of the repurchase of certain non-redeemable, non-participating preference shares. The applicant was a public company which issued preference shares to certain persons. It decided to repurchase the shares at their current market value. The purchase price would be less than the issue price.

Forum shopping – who decides on legal status of assessments?
South Africa | May 23 2014

The North Gauteng High Court was recently faced with the question of whether the High Court has the necessary jurisdiction to rule on the legal status of income tax assessments. It is clear from the judgment that courts discourage 'forum shopping' applications by parties, as it could not have been the legislature's intention to create competing and concurrent forums for the resolution of tax disputes.

Withdrawal of assessments under the Tax Administration Act
South Africa | April 17 2014

Section 98 of the Tax Administration Act provides for the withdrawal of an assessment by the South African Revenue Service (SARS) in certain circumstances. Recent amendments have now extended its ambit by introducing further circumstances in which SARS may withdraw an assessment, including an undisputed factual error by the taxpayer in a return, a processing error by SARS or fraudulent submission of a return.

Legal professional privilege and invoices from attorneys
South Africa | April 11 2014

The Western Cape High Court recently decided a dispute regarding legal professional privilege between three companies in a group of companies and the South African Revenue Service. The court confirmed that the rationale for privilege is that the confidentiality that it bestows is necessary for the proper functioning of the legal system, and that fee notes are not by their nature subject to legal professional privilege.

Exemption employee share ownership plan rulings
South Africa | March 14 2014

The tax implications for the various participants of a share incentive scheme are complex and the legislation is not necessarily clear. In recent years the South African Revenue Service and the National Treasury have focused on share incentive schemes and made regular amendments to the tax legislation and issued a number of binding private and class rulings.

Ruling on definition of 'listed shares'
South Africa | March 07 2014

Under the Income Tax Act, a foreign dividend will be tax exempt to the extent that it is paid in respect of a listed share and does not constitute a distribution of an asset in specie. The issue that arises in these circumstances is whether the preferred securities constitute listed shares and whether the South African investors would be able to rely on the foreign dividend exemption in respect of dividends paid on them.

Determining a 'group of companies' for purposes of the corporate rules
South Africa | January 24 2014

The Income Tax Act (58/1962) contains a definition of a 'group of companies' in Section 1. However, a narrower definition of the term is contained in Section 41 which applies to certain corporate tax roll-over rules and other provisions contained in the act. It is important to identify which companies fall within the different definitions in order to determine whether one qualifies for the applicable tax relief.

Deductibility of empowerment costs
South Africa | December 13 2013

Costs associated with black economic empowerment transactions are akin to obtaining a licence to operate, and thus should form part of the income earning operations of the company. The Income Tax Act contains provisions relating to deductibility of specific expenditure, some of which have been identified as possibilities for the deduction of expenditure relating to indirect black economic empowerment measures.

Supply of services for contingent consideration
South Africa | October 11 2013

The recent Taxation Laws Amendment Bill 2013 proposed a new section dealing with time-of-supply rules for contingent services. The proposal should amend an existing anomaly by implementing special time-of-supply rules that will apply to both goods and services – more specifically, where consideration for the performance must still be ascertained or can be ascertained only at a later date.

Binding private ruling on foreign asset-for-share transaction
South Africa | September 20 2013

The South African Revenue Service (SARS) recently released Binding Private Ruling 149, which dealt with the disposal by a local company of foreign assets in exchange for shares in a foreign company. SARS had to rule whether a transaction fell within the definition of an 'asset-for-share transaction', as defined in Section 42 of the Income Tax Act, and thus qualified for rollover relief.

Binding class ruling on dividends distributed by a foreign company
South Africa | September 06 2013

The South African Revenue Service recently issued Binding Class Ruling 41 regarding the question of whether a dividend distributed by a foreign company constitutes a 'foreign dividend' as defined in Section 1 of the Income Tax Act. The ruling dealt with whether the applicant could be considered to be distributing foreign dividends where it made distributions to beneficial holders of depositary receipts locally.

Transferee liable for tax debts of taxpayer
South Africa | July 19 2013

Under the Tax Administration Act, which took effect in October 2012, if a transferee receives an asset from a taxpayer who is a connected person in relation to the transferee without consideration or for consideration which is below the fair market value of the asset, the transferee is liable for the tax debt of the taxpayer. However, in so providing, the legislature appears to have cast its net too wide.

Ruling on dividends tax on shares held by local branches
South Africa | July 12 2013

The South African Revenue Service recently published Binding Private Ruling 148, which dealt with whether the dividends tax rate applicable to dividends paid on shares held by a local branch of a foreign company can be reduced by a relevant double tax agreement. The applicant in this case was a South African company that was part of a global group headquartered in Japan.

Media, Marketing, Sports & Entertainment

Lights, camera, action! Tax exemption for films
South Africa | October 26 2017

Section 12O of the Income Tax Act provides an incentive to stimulate the domestic production of films in the form of an exemption from normal tax for income derived from the exploitation rights of a film. The South African Revenue Service recently issued guidance reflecting its interpretation of this provision.

Real Estate

Residential property developers face cash-flow crunch due to VAT on temporary letting of units
South Africa | April 06 2018

Many residential property developers will begin 2018 with a major cash-flow challenge, as they may be faced with a substantial value added tax (VAT) liability in respect of the temporary letting of residential units which have been developed for resale. It is hoped that the South African Revenue Service and the National Treasury will urgently address the problems with regard to the VAT rules concerning the change-in-use adjustments for property developers.